Just my Thoughts · Politics

Health Care Reform and President Obama

In the two year primary and general election season that was the 2008 presidential election, health care was a hot topic.  Then, the economy started to tank and people were talking less about health care but the health care industry was still a mess.

Tonight, President Obama took his health insurance reform to the American people with a prime time news conference.  He opened with remarks about where we are, as opposed to six months ago when he took office.  He discussed the economy and its start of a recovery and the monies that have been spent on this effort so far.

In looking back over the news conference, this opening may have been the most concrete period of the entire news conference.  President Obama could recite facts and figures and was reading prepared remarks.  He knew that what he was saying was true.  There were few times when anything he stated could be questioned.

The president says that people are coming around to this plan, that Congress has come far and that the hardest part now is to find the 1/3 funding that has not been found yet.  The plan in Congress, being discussed and changed at this moment, will limit out of pocket costs, will cover preventative care, will not allow denial based on preexisting conditions.  The big question is how to pay for the proposals that will change the incentives for big business – whether prescriptive, hospital, doctor or otherwise.

Ben Feller, of The Associated Press, wanted to know what ways of paying for the 1/3 of the cost that is not covered by reallocating dollars wasted in the current federal health care system the President thought were best.  Had the President told Congress how to pay for this portion?  Were there ways the President would not accept?

President Obama seems comfortable throwing out numbers.  He stated that health insurance premiums are increasing three times faster than inflation.  The average family pays over six thousand dollars more than in other advanced countries.  So, there is evidently a problem that needs to be and can be fixed.  Reforming health insurance will be deficit nuetral.  The only portion currently being argued over is 1/3 of the cost.  President Obama has suggested limiting itemized deductions for the wealthiest of Americans.  He says this will pay for the 1/3 of the cost.  He does not want, and will not sign, a bill that puts the 1/3 of the cost not found yet on the backs of middle class America.  There are many ideas in Congress and this is an area that, while the President believes his idea is best, he admits there are many possible answers.

President Obama also stated that over the last decade, the middle class has seen its income flatline as health care costs have gobbled up what would be increases in income.  Folks are skeptical about change.

David Alexander of Reuters asked why the rush for change.  Quite easily, President Obama explained that there is a rush because of the letters he is receiving daily from families getting clobbered by health care costs.  He also readily admitted that if there is no deadline in Washington, nothing happens.  Doing something different always makes someone unhappy.  Someone will like the status quo.  This is why there is a necessity to set a deadline so that change can actually occur.

President Obama also took questions on what sacrifices would be required from a new health insurance system.  He took questions on what sacrifices Medicare recipients would have to make.  The questions that he answered that were specific to health insurance reform, he seemed comfortable with and more than ready to answer.

Then, came the later part of the press conference.  There was a question from someone why health care reform negotiations were not being televised on C-SPAN and, to further the question of transparency – which, if you recall, was a big issue in the campaign last fall, why requests for a list of health care executives who have visited the White House had not been released.  Finally, this question involved TARP transparency complaints.

Obama seemed to not like being on the defensive.  He didn’t like that someone was pointing out that a promise from the campaign was not being fulfilled.  It seems that President Obama is now realizing that everything he said in October and September may not have been possible as he does not have control over everything.  Consequently, he cannot force C-SPAN to cover the multiple committee meetings that are regarding health insurance reform.  President Obama also told the reporter that he did not know about the TARP question but would find out.

The press conference wrapped up with Lynn Sweet asking about the arrest, and subsequent dropping of charges against, of Professor Gates in Cambridge.  While I do believe that the Cambridge police screwed up on this arrest from all I have read, I do not believe that the President of the United States, whether friends with the man or not, should say the police department screwed up while on national television.

With this having been one of many of President Obama’s prime time news conferences, the public is getting use to seeing the President respond to questions from the press.  He takes most in stride.  If tonight had a goal of getting the American people to decide they like the idea of health insurance reform, it was short on details.  The only detail I came away with is that 2/3 of the cost is going to be paid for by reallocating wasteful spending.  Nothing about what was said made me think that this reform is urgent or that I should support it.

2 thoughts on “Health Care Reform and President Obama

  1. But something has to be done. More and more of us lose jobs and consequently lose medical benefits. More and more of us accept part-time jobs that have no benefits attached to them because there is nothing else out there. Businesses, organizations, institutions know this and right now many are only offering part-time work as a way to defray the cost of human capital at the expense of humanity. At least this president has the moral strength and political bravery to bring this issue back into the American conscience. As you recall with Bill Clinton, it was political suicide.

    There are so many issues this country needs to address but fear is a terrible detractor. So many people still suffer physically, socially, mentally, because of it. We now have a leader who is embracing fear and forcing us to address our conscience

  2. You are totally right, Steve. Something has to be done. The bigger problem is selling the American people on what the government is doing. As the president said last night – and I paraphrase, it is usually easier dealing with the devil you know than the one you don’t.

    While I wrote about what was said last night, I left out the bigger picture. Changing health care would mean so much to so many – not just the 47 million who are currently uninsured (although that is last fall’s number and I believe I heard that 14,000 lose their insurance daily).

    There would be less fear from women in abusive situations to leave if they knew that they and their children would not be uninsured once out of the marriage. I know people will think this is a stretch but it truly is not. Many people stay in situations they should not because a child has a chronic medical condition. Great, and I mean that sarcastically, since it is so much better for a child to his parent abused – whether verbal or physical abuse – as opposed to getting treatment for asthma. When push comes to shove, most parents choose for the child, not for themselves. But does that, in the end, provide what is best for the child?

    The part-time job issue also is a huge problem. So is the self-employed issue and those who work for very small businesses that do not provide health coverage at all.

    There are so many areas that health insurance and care reform will make better. It is definitely one of the third rails of our political system. My bigger concern, and I do agree with the President that if a deadline is not set in Washington nothing gets done, is that we are rushing into this too quickly. Congress will pass a bill that will help, of that I am sure, but whether it is the right way to help I am not so sure.

    And, if anyone has read this far, here are two links to additional thoughts on health care:



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.