Tag Archives: domesticviolence

Victims, Self-Defense and Violence

My mind seems to be drawn towards these three words this morning:  victims, self-defense, and violence.  I can pinpoint why as I read some creative writing that was masochistic and a news article on a domestic violence advocate and a blog on self-defense.  The combination of the three of these has set my mind moving in deep, mostly dark ways.

First, I cringe at the fact that the domestic violence advocate is from the Crime Victim’s Assistance Center.  Yes, domestic violence is a crime.  My problem comes with the word victim.  When we, as a society, assign the word victim to someone, we take away who they are.  Domestic violence has already done that to the person experiencing it.  Domestic violence has removed the “safe” from the home and has taken away any identifying factors the person experiencing it may have had with that home and that family group.  The last thing that person then needs is to be told he or she is a victim.

MindBodyMama’s blog entry on self-defense also brought about a word I dislike.  She talked about how women, and it is true that is mostly women that think this way, say they were “lucky” when they ward off an attack, when they defend themselves.  I have never in my life heard a man say he was lucky to not get mugged in a parking lot because he hit the attacker.  I have never in my life heard a man say he was lucky to not be raped by that woman.  Why do women presume that it is luck that allowed them to escape injury or danger?  A societal norm that women are not strong enough to defend themselves, a fairy tale read in youth that says someone will save you play into the reasoning women think escape is luck.

We all, men and women, deserve to live safe, healthy, happy lives without luck playing into our safety.  We need to be able to defend ourselves and to know that we are worthy of safety.  We need to know that we are not victims in our own lives.


City School Districts

I have always encouraged my daughter, who is a senior at Niagara University and will graduate with a degree in elementary education and a minor in literacy, to stay in the Niagara area and student teach.  My theory was that even the “city” school districts in our area are not true inner city school districts.  She needs to know what teaching in such a district would be like to be sure she would want to do that if offered a job in such a district.

She listened to my arguments and did stay in Niagara to student teach.  Her first placement was in a kindergarten class in Colonial Village in the Niagara-Wheatfield district.  She compared the school to the elementary school her younger siblings went to here locally – Maine Memorial.  She loved the kindergarten class.  Her only real shock was that most of the kindergarten kids had not been in an organized school setting previously.

She is now in her second placement.  This is in a third grade class in the Niagara Falls City District.  I received a call after she got back to her apartment yesterday.  When she got to school, the teachers were all gathered around and talking like something big was going on.  It was. 

Over the weekend, a man in Niagara Falls had shot and killed his estranged wife.  The couple had a child at the school.  The man was still at large.  My daughter was in total amazement.  There was no offer of counselling for students, or staff for that matter, by the school.  The building was not on lock down.  As far as the principal was concerned, this was just another Monday at 79th Street school.

I don’t know what would happen under the same circumstances in this area.  Hopefully, I never will find out.  I do believe, though, that local districts – especially with the father still at large – would have been under lock down.  I also want to believe that counseling would be offered for both students and staff.

In retrospect, the lock down was not necessary.  Articles in this morning’s Buffalo News and Niagara Gazette indicate that the father killed himself, most likely on Sunday evening.

Is this the reaction you would expect from the district your children attend?  What reaction do you think should have been taken?


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,870 other followers